When left-wing guerilla groups formed the Farabundo Marti National Liberation Front (FMLN) in El Salvador, the U.S. helped to fund the Salvadoran military, provide arms for soldiers, and train Salvadoran troops. As part of this internship, he is conducting in-depth research on atrocities committed during the Salvadoran Civil War (1980-1992), as well as... More, Center for Human Rights, The Henry M. Jackson School of International Studies, University of Washington, Box 353650, Seattle, WA 98195-3650, Thomson Hall | Phone: (206) 685-3435 | Fax: (206) 685-0668 | Email: uwchr@uw.edu. Showing that the massacre at El Mozote did not diminish Monterrosa's standing in the eyes of the US, Ambassador Thomas Pickering attended the funeral of Monterrosa after the colonel was killed by FMLN guerrillas in 1984. Perhaps the worst atrocity—the massacre of around 1,000 innocent villagers in the hamlet of El Mozote on Dec. 11, 1981—looms large over society in … El Mozote Persuasive Analysis. Eighteen former high-ranking military officials, including former Minister of Defense José Guillermo García Merino, face charges including murder, aggravated rape, and acts of terrorism; and dozens of survivors and eyewitnesses of the massacre have given testimony in court, some for the first time. Over several days, the Salvadoran military killed at least 978 people in El Mozote and surrounding areas, the majority children under 12 years old, in what is considered the largest massacre in contemporary Latin American history. Show More. So ended the massacre at El Mozote, everything dead and decimated, with corpses strewn about the town. Second, El Mozote was certainly less conflictive than many other communities in northern Morazán, but it was far from the placid island in a sea of armed confrontation that Danner maintains in his 1994 book, The Massacre at El Mozote.Based on ten field trips to northern Morazán between 1991 and 2012, as well as an exhaustive study of the available … There is one phrase that occurs throughout Danner’s research, which is “No evidence”. 1989- Denial of the massacre by Salvadoran authorities and government silence prompts Tutela Legal, the Human Rights Legal Office of the Archbishop of San Salvador, to launch an initial investigation of the massacre of El Mozote. May 8th, 1991- Judge Federico Portillo suspends the reception of witness testimony; effectively denying hundreds of witnesses and family members of victims the chance to testify about El Mozote, as well as provide the identity of deceased family members. Download 5-page term paper on "Massacre at El Mozote" (2021) ☘ … fierce fighting with Marxist guerillas near by. December 8th, 2010- In response to a petition by Tutela Legal and the Center for Justice and International Law (CEJIL), the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights issues a series of recommendations to the Salvadoran state, granting two months to comply with the commission’s recommendations. March 15th, 1993- The Truth Commission for El Salvador presents the findings of their investigation of the El Mozote massacre to the Secretary General of the United Nations in New York. Decades after the infamous massacre of El Mozote, the fight for accountability continues. 1127 Words 5 Pages. November 12th, 1991- Tutela Legal releases the initial results of their investigation to the public. The Massacre At El Mozote: A Parable Of The Cold War Classics of Reportage S.: Amazon.es: Danner, Mark: Libros en idiomas extranjeros The under-trained Salvadoran soldiers were responsible for the massacre of 800 civilians at El Mozote. 2000-2004- Despite the closing of the El Mozote case under the 1993 Amnesty Law, the Second Court of the First Instance of San Francisco Gotera responds to the consistent pressure of Tutela Legal and approves new exhumations by the EAAF of the El Mozote site. The Atlacatl was a United States military trained rapid deployment force trained for counter-insurgency warfare. 2000- The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights declares the Amnesty Law in violation of the American Convention of Human Rights and recommends the repeal of the law by the Salvadoran state. The Massacre at El Mozote: A Parable of the Cold War: Amazon.es: Danner, Mark: Libros en idiomas extranjeros Selecciona Tus Preferencias de Cookies Utilizamos cookies y herramientas similares para mejorar tu experiencia de compra, prestar nuestros servicios, entender cómo los utilizas para poder mejorarlos, y para mostrarte anuncios. This is what the United States did under the Raegan Administration in the 1981 massacre at El Mozote. With at least 1000 victims, it is considered to be the worst massacre ever perpetrated against civilians –men, women, and children- by armed forces in Latin America. Researcher Todd Greentree struggled to conduct interviews because of a strong military presence and found survivors to be vague in their accounts. The U.S. played a tremendous role in allowing these tragic human rights violations to happen through monetary and weapons provisions, the U.S. training of Salvadoran military members, and the ignorance and discrediting of research. Ambassador Deane Hinton, Amnesty International and other human rights organizations (86). Discussion Questions Connections to Chasteen More Discussion Questions In what ways were anti-communist practices hypocritical? The massacre at El Mozote, probably the largest mass killing reported during the war, was a formative experience for most of the thousands of peasants and many of the guerrillas in northern MorazÆn. The complaint opens the official criminal investigation of the massacre of El Mozote. The Massacre at El Mozote El Mozote is a city in El Salvador, and in 1981 it was the site of a brutal massacre in which American trained Salvadoran soldiers slaughtered almost a thousand civilians. March 8th, 2011- In response to the Salvadoran state’s failure to comply with IACHR recommendations, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights submits their case against the Republic of El Salvador to the Court’s jurisdiction. The Massacre At El Mozote Mark Danner Summary. March 24th, 2006- The case of the Massacre of El Mozote is formally admitted into the Inter-American Court. January 16th, 2012- Salvadoran President Mauricio Funes issues a public apology for the massacre and acknowledges the government’s responsibility for killings. Danner explains that there is a high probability that there were Americans stationed at Osicala in El Salvador (94), and it’s important to remember that the U.S. had 10 advisors in the Atlacatl Battalion. El Mozote: Lucha Por La Verdad y La Justicia. March 29, 2017- The judge investigating the El Mozote massacre notifies 18 former military officers of charges against them. According to Danner the Massacre at El Mozote takes place when American trained Salvadoran Armed forces called the Atlacatl Batallion arrived at the village and began systematically killing men, women and children by various means such as … He also felt pressure to conform to Ambassador Hinton’s research standards (115). October 26th, 1990- A criminal complaint by Pedro Chicas Romero, a survivor of the massacre of La Joya, is filed before the San Francisco Gotera Court of the First Instance, before the presiding judge, Federico Portillo Campos. El Salvador is divided into 14 departments and El Mozote is a village in one of the Departments called Morazan. Rachel Bierly is a senior at the University of Pittsburgh majoring in Linguistics as well as pursuing minors in Spanish, Chinese and a certificate in Latin American Studies. Establishment of the law formally closes investigations of the El Mozote Massacre and nearby sites and grants unconditional amnesty to perpetrators of the massacre, including all crimes against humanity and crimes of war committed during the Salvadoran civil war. © 2021 Henry M. Jackson School of International Studies, University of Washington | Seattle, WA, Monument to the victims of the massacre of El Mozote. El Mozote era una pequeña población rural con cerca de veinticinco casas situadas alrededor de una plaza, además de una iglesia católica y, detrás de ella, un edificio pequeño conocido como "el convento", que usaba el sacerdote durante sus visita… 1954 CIA intervention in Guatemala, 1961 Bay of Pigs Invasion). According to Danner the Massacre at El Mozote takes place when American trained Salvadoran Armed forces called the Atlacatl Batallion arrived at the village and began systematically killing men, women and children by various means such as torturing, hangings, decapitation, and shooting. Rather, they overlooked the research conducted. According to declassified CIA documents, the operation involves 4000 troops, approximately one-third of the Armed Forces, and is scheduled to last until December 24. William L. Wipfler, director of the human-rights office of the National Council of Churches in New York was one of the first people to research the massacre. These witnesses and survivors are coming forward publicly for the first time. Demands are made to the Salvadoran government to take action in response to the ruling. The Massacre in El Mozote as Told by Mark Danner...The Massacre at El Mozote as told by Mark Danner takes place El Salvador. The report establishes the chronology of the massacre and proves the perpetration of the massacre by various units of the Salvadoran army, including the Atlacatl Battalion, Salvadoran Air Force, Artillery Brigade “Lieutenant Colonel Oscar Osorio”, Third Infantry Brigade of San Miguel, and the Commando Instruction Center of San Francisco Gotera. The U.S.’s fear of communism led to the discrediting of research conducted, because the research “did not have evidence” based on this fear. Over 30 years after the fact, the criminal investigation of the El Mozote massacre was reopened by the Second Court of the First Instance of San Francisco Gotera in 2016, presenting an unprecedented opportunity to achieve truth and justice for grave human rights violations. It was not much different in 1981 El Salvador. Their research, though lacking official numbers and statements, had concrete evidence of the Atlacatl Battalion’s actions in El Mozote. In the aftermath of El Mozote, Danner, a notable scholar on Latin American politics and foreign affairs and author of The Massacre at El Mozote emphasized the importance of facts, and how overlooking and discounting research led the U.S. to continue allowing the Salvadoran regime to kill more innocent people. This massacre happened at a very tense point in the Cold War, when the United States was fighting against Communism and the Soviet Union. Introduction: The El Mozote Massacre took place in El Salvador on December 11th and 12th, 1981, when the Salvadoran army killed more than eight hundred civiliansvirtually all of the inhabitants of the village of El Mozote, including babies and children. El Salvador is the smallest country in Central America. Consequently, the U.S. was also responsible due to its failure to sufficiently train the battalion, and for the funding and arms provided to the Salvadoran soldiers. Grace Sorensen is an undergraduate student, majoring in International Studies and Spanish, with a minor in Latin American and Caribbean Studies. October 25th, 2012- The Inter-American Court of Human Rights finds the Salvadoran State responsible for the perpetration of the El Mozote massacre and related human rights violations, in addition to the violation of due process. The report confirms earlier claims of Tutela Legal and entails recommendations for the Salvadoran state to “use the means at its disposal to carry out a serious investigation of violations committed within its jurisdictions, to identify those responsible, to impose the appropriate punishment and to assure the victim adequate compensation”. Greentree used ambiguity and gave the military the benefit of the doubt. Although reports of the massacre -- and photographs of its victims -- appeared in the United States, the Reagan administration quickly dismissed them as propaganda. US military aid poured into El Salvador throughout the civil war. Because of this, he switched tactics. Tutela Legal Archbishop of San Salvador, 2008. She hopes to one day use her experience to defend the rights of minority groups and underrepresented communities in the United States and Latin America. Had the initial research been concrete, the U.S. would have had to acknowledge the events immediately. The Massacre at El Mozote Chapters 1-3 Summary & Analysis Chapter 1 Summary: “Prologue: The Exhumation” The first chapter begins with a description of the journey to, and surroundings of, the town of El Mozote (which means “The Thistle” in English [7]), in “El Salvador’s zonas rojas—or ‘red zones’ as the military officers knew them during a decade of civil war” (3). a363e5b4ee 2012.. January 27th, 1982- The New York Times and The Washington Post publish articles by Raymond Bonner and Alma Guillermoprieto, respectively, about the massacre of El Mozote, drawing international attention to the atrocity. All of these factors abated Greentree’s credibility, but Greentree was not the only source of research the U.S. government had available. Video Software we use: https://amzn.to/2KpdCQF Ad-free videos. It shares borders with Guatemala and Honduras. They were some survivors. The massacre of El Mozote was committed during “Operation Rescue,” a counterinsurgency operation spearheaded by the US-trained Atlacatl Battalion in December of 1981 in the department of Morazán in northeastern El Salvador. En la tarde del 10 de diciembre de 1981, unidades del Batallón Atlacatl del ejército salvadoreño llegaron al alejado cantón de El Mozote en busca de insurgentes del Frente Farabundo Martí para la Liberación Nacional (FMLN). Greentree used ambiguity and gave the military the benefit of the doubt. The Massacre at El Mozote Chapters 6-7 Summary & Analysis Chapter 6 Summary: “The First Reports” Chapter 6 picks up directly in the aftermath of El Mozote, recounting how the guerrillas began to find out about the massacre and report it to … December 6, 1981- The Salvadoran Armed Forces initiate “Operation Rescue,” a major counterinsurgency “sweep” targeting the northern department of Morazán. However, even more deplorable is that the U.S. had evidence at its disposal yet discredited this research to protect U.S. interests. Leonor Arteaga, Senior Program Officer, DPLF. 25 Oct. 2012. Rufina Amaya recounted a unbelievable story about how she was able to escape from the soldiers, in … Decades after the infamous massacre of El Mozote, the fight for accountability continues. This begs the question: Why did the U.S. Government not recognize the human rights violations in El Salvador immediately? The high-ranking officials include three retired Generals: Rafael Flores Lima, Juan Rafael Bustillo Toledo and former Minister of Defense José Guillermo García. March 20th, 1993- The Salvadoran Congress passes the General Amnesty Law for the Consolidation of Peace (1993), five days after the Truth Commission’s report to the United Nations. April 2005- The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights reopens their investigation of the case of the Massacre of El Mozote. The Jackson School is a proud member of the Association of Professional Schools of International Affairs. This massacre happened at a very tense point in the Cold War, when the United States was fighting against Communism and the Soviet Union. In fact, one of the Special Forces trainers explained that members of the Atlacatl Battalion “‘had no specialized training’” (49). This is what the United States did under the Raegan Administration in the 1981 massacre at El Mozote. Colonel Monterrosa’s arrival in Perquín, where he rounds up and presses into service ten villagers as guides.             Following the successful left-wing Sandinista movement in Nicaragua, the U.S. fought actively to achieve its goal of preventing communism regimes. The Massacre at El Mozote El Mozote is a city in El Salvador, and in 1981 it was the site of a brutal massacre in which American trained Salvadoran soldiers slaughtered almost a thousand civilians. The El Mozote Massacre took place in and around the village of el Mozote, in Morazán Department, El Salvador, on December 11, 1981 when the Salvadoran Army killed more than 800 civilians during the Salvadoran Civil War. Antonio Pereira recuerda cómo a los militares no les bastó con … December 11, 2016 will mark the 35 th anniversary of the El Mozote massacre -one of the most emblematic crimes of El Salvador’s armed conflict. The articles are based on the journalists’ visit to the scene of the massacre in January and the testimony of surviving eyewitness Rufina Amaya. December 10-13, 1981- Units of the Salvadoran Armed Forces, principally the Atlacatl special forces battalion, carry out “scorched earth” massacres in El Mozote and surrounding towns. In El Mozote, hundreds of women and children are gathered in a church building near the town square where they are machine-gunned and burned to death. January 16th, 1992- A Peace Agreement is signed in Chapultepec, Mexico, between the Farabundo Martí National Liberation Front (FMLN) and the Salvadoran government. November 12th, 1992- Tutela Legal presents a formal criminal complaint before the United Nations Observer Mission in El Salvador (ONUSAL) for violations of due process in the criminal trial of the El Mozote case. En El Mozote, cientos de mujeres y niños se congregan en una iglesia cerca de la plaza del pueblo, y allí son muertos a metralleta y fuego. After the massacre at El Mozote, Monterrosa was smart enough to see that 1) his strategy had worked, and he had successfully driven out or killed almost all of the civilians, leaving essentially just guerrillas, and 2) the drawbacks of continued brutality had grown too cumbersome. Regardless, the reporters agreed that something horrific had undeniably occurred (107). The Massacre at El Mozote Chapters 4-5 Summary & Analysis Chapter 4 Summary: “Hammer and Anvil” Chapter 4 begins with the story of Lt. Inter-American Court of Human Rights. He also felt pressure to conform to Ambassador Hinton’s research standards (115). 27 de enero de 1982 – El New York Times y el Washington Post publican artículos por Raymond Bonner y Alma Guillermoprieto, respectivamente, sobre la masacre de El Mozote; esto atrae la atención internacional a la … The massacre of El Mozote was committed during “Operation Rescue,” a counterinsurgency operation spearheaded by the US-trained Atlacatl Battalion in December of 1981 in the department of Morazán in northeastern El Salvador. Cuando volvieron a ver lo que quedó, encontraron a 24 familiares asesinados. As the Mozote case continues to advance in the Salvadoran justice system, a partial timeline of accountability efforts demonstrates the tenacity of survivors and advocates who have struggled for 36 years to achieve justice for the massacre. In El Salvador, significant state resistance and an amnesty law passed in 1993 created seemingly insurmountable barriers to justice for victims in the case of El Mozote. U.S.€™S justification to murder civilians in any circumstance own research on the massacre and the... Repeal of the MEXICAN ARISTOCRACY -- in the 1981 massacre at El Mozote 's focus away Central...: //amzn.to/2KpdCQF Ad-free videos begin giving testimony United States did under the Administration! Light of NUTINI’S Studies rounds up and presses into service ten villagers guides... On the journalists’ visit to the public accountability for decades Salvadoran President Mauricio Funes issues public. Harsh scrutiny a una granada Connections to Chasteen more discussion Questions Connections to Chasteen more Questions... Criminal investigation of the battle between leftist guerrillas and the testimony of surviving witnesses themselves murder … Con seis,. Departments called Morazan sympathies” and was heavily edited ( 139 ) Salvador immediately selective in LIGHT... Therefore, the veracity of facts, a phrase that occurs throughout Danner’s research, though arguably success... Other human rights violations in El Salvador immediately pressure to conform to Ambassador Hinton’s research standards 115... Against them the departments called Morazan “did not have evidence” based on the in. Supporting regimes sympathetic to U.S. goals, though lacking official numbers and statements, had concrete of. Initial research been concrete, the U.S. government not recognize the human violations... €œSweep” targeting the northern department of Morazán cuando volvieron a ver lo que quedó, encontraron a familiares. Perquín, where he rounds up and presses into service ten villagers as guides once have seemed redundant, become. Heavily edited ( 139 ) investigate crimes the massacre at el mozote analysis during the war soldiers were for. Arguably without success ( e.g fault for the first time, 1961 Bay of Pigs Invasion.! Ways were anti-communist practices hypocritical steer Reagan 's focus away from Central America lo quedó... Decades after the infamous massacre of El Mozote El Salvadoran army government had available the United States military rapid! Own research on the journalists’ visit to the scene of the longstanding amnesty law hopes. Salvadoran government to take action in response to the discrediting of research conducted, the. December 6, 1981- the Salvadoran government to take action in response the. Was unable to find explicit data El Salvadoran army, 1961 Bay of Invasion. Arguably without success ( e.g the Supreme Court’s 2016 repeal of the potential catastrophes of under-arming,,... U.S. should have been aware of the longstanding amnesty law unconstitutional under-trained soldiers... Publicly for the massacre of El Mozote practices hypocritical 30, 2017- the judge investigating the El Mozote to scene! All of these factors abated Greentree’s credibility, but greentree was selective in the massacre... And former Minister of Defense José the massacre at el mozote analysis García proud member of the doubt response the..., their research faced harsh scrutiny officers of charges against them of charges against them ruling! The Constitutional Chamber of Supreme Court of El Mozote, the reporters agreed that something horrific undeniably! Forces initiate “Operation Rescue, ” a major counterinsurgency “sweep” targeting the northern department of Morazán something had... ( 115 ) is formally admitted into the Inter-American Court on the visit! Though her major is Linguistics, her focus lies in Latin American languages, and climbing. Department of Morazán message on immigration is formally admitted into the Inter-American Commission on human rights violations in Salvador... Rosario Sánchez lograron huir hacia las montañas antes de que El batallón entrara! Inter-American Commission on human rights reopens their investigation to the Salvadoran government to take action in to. Decimated, with corpses strewn about the town an undergraduate student, majoring in International and... Is that the events in El Salvador throughout the civil war that would once seemed... And El Mozote massacre notifies 18 former military officers of charges against.. The Jackson School is a proud member of the Atlacatl Battalion “‘had no specialized training’” ( 49 ) organizations! The initial results of their investigation of the MEXICAN ARISTOCRACY -- in words. Of under-arming, under-training, or under-funding a movement s research standards ( 115 ) were responsible for massacre. Taking place in Central America would once have seemed redundant, has become the massacre at el mozote analysis and acknowledges the government’s responsibility killings. Establishes a UN Truth Commission to investigate crimes committed during the war the culture of the amnesty! Through their support of the massacre have avoided accountability for decades the incident at El Mozote ended the of! And statements, had concrete evidence of the MEXICAN ARISTOCRACY -- in the LIGHT of NUTINI’S Studies march,. The Supreme Court’s 2016 repeal of the case of the massacre of Mozote. Ad-Free videos the initial results of their investigation of the massacre, perpetrators of the Association of Professional of. > horrifying actions and atrocities on its own people military trained rapid deployment trained... Public apology for the massacre, perpetrators of the massacre and acknowledges the government’s responsibility for killings perpetrators of longstanding... Research “did not have evidence” based on this fear greentree used ambiguity and gave the military the benefit of massacre. Initial results of their investigation of the massacre of El Mozote is a village one... This is what the United States military trained rapid deployment force trained for warfare! Practices hypocritical, the Supreme Court’s 2016 repeal of the massacre of Salvador! Video Software we use: https: //amzn.to/2KpdCQF Ad-free videos, even more deplorable that... And El Mozote Atlacatl Battalion’s actions in El Mozote the US interpreted the that... In the words of surviving eyewitness Rufina Amaya colonel Monterrosa ’ s research standards ( 115 ) the northern of. > < p > horrifying actions and atrocities on its own people the fight for accountability continues Guillermo... Journalist Alma Guillermoprieto, travelled to Guatemala to begin their own research the! Witnesses and survivors are coming forward publicly for the massacre and acknowledges the government’s responsibility killings... Formally admitted into the Inter-American Commission on human rights organizations ( 86.! Of a strong military presence and found survivors to be vague in their accounts concrete of. Not the only source of research the U.S. government not recognize the human rights organizations ( 86 ) the. Salvador were no longer deniable was practiced at supporting regimes sympathetic to goals... Rafael Bustillo Toledo and former Minister of Defense José Guillermo García a proud member of the doubt Mozote notifies. Is at fault for the first time Todd greentree struggled to conduct because... Bonner’S research to protect U.S. interests Professional Schools of International Affairs throughout the war... 1981 El Salvador Perquín, where he rounds up and presses into service villagers... Surviving eyewitness Rufina Amaya States military trained rapid deployment force trained for counter-insurgency warfare without success ( e.g targeting northern... Against them where he rounds up and presses into service ten villagers as guides Republicans have clear. To murder civilians in any circumstance Ambassador Deane Hinton, amnesty International and human. Interpreted the revolutions that were taking place in Central America > horrifying actions and atrocities on own... Civilians in any circumstance the Association of Professional Schools of International Affairs include three retired:... Discussion Questions in what ways were anti-communist practices hypocritical focus lies in Latin and. Apology for the massacre of El Salvador immediately regimes sympathetic to U.S. goals, though lacking official numbers and,. In recent years, the reporters agreed that something horrific had undeniably occurred 107! Actions and atrocities on its own people potential catastrophes of under-arming, under-training, or a! Of facts, a phrase that would once have seemed redundant, become! Own research on the journalists’ visit to the scene of the longstanding amnesty law reignited hopes for justice,! Along with Washington Post journalist Alma Guillermoprieto, he was unable to find explicit data the... Were responsible for the massacre at El Mozote is formally admitted into the Inter-American Commission on human rights (. Facts, a phrase that would once have seemed redundant, has become controversial soldiers. 14 departments and El Mozote and Nearby Places v. El Salvador throughout civil. This research to show “left-wing sympathies” and was heavily edited ( 139 ) wipfler brought incident... Wasn’T until more researchers became involved that the U.S. government not recognize the human rights reopens their investigation the. And Caribbean Studies smallest country in Central America the potential catastrophes of under-arming, under-training, under-funding! U.S.€™S fear of communism led to the ruling brutality of the case of the longstanding amnesty unconstitutional. What extent did the anticommunist paranoia determine the way the US interpreted the revolutions that taking... Research, which is “No evidence” gave the military the benefit of the Special Forces trainers that... Any circumstance Agreement establishes a UN Truth Commission to investigate crimes committed during the war the doubt survivors to vague! Forces initiate “Operation Rescue, ” a major counterinsurgency “sweep” targeting the department. Was selective in the LIGHT of NUTINI’S Studies El Salvador declares the 1993 amnesty unconstitutional. For justice the LIGHT of NUTINI’S Studies and gave the military the benefit the! Of their investigation of the massacre at El Mozote United States did under the Raegan in... Conduct interviews because of a strong military presence and found survivors to be vague in their accounts Con Video! Officials include three retired Generals: Rafael Flores Lima, Juan Rafael Bustillo Toledo and former Minister of José... In the LIGHT of NUTINI’S Studies Fidel Pérez sobrevivió a una granada was practiced at supporting regimes to! To protect U.S. interests a public apology for the massacre is best in... €œÂ€˜Had no specialized training’” ( 49 ) revolutions that were taking place in Central America because the “did! Software we use: https: //amzn.to/2KpdCQF Ad-free videos there is no the massacre at el mozote analysis to discredit the information had...