Indirect losses, often referred to in business insurance policies as "consequential losses," are not inflicted by the peril itself but describe losses suffered as a result or consequence of the direct loss. Indirect, or consequential, loss is that which could have reasonably been contemplated by someone with knowledge of special circumstances outside the usual course of things. For example, profit can be held by the courts to be a direct loss (British Sugar plc v NEI Power Projects Ltd and Another (1997)) or it may be considered that some component of profit is a direct … However, it looks like the courts will, in future, be more inclined to interpret ‘consequential and indirect loss’ to mean what any reasonable person would think the words mean – if that is what the context and wording of the contract make clear. Under the agreement, the … Consequential damages therefore require certainty as to the amount of loss, foreseeability of loss incurred as a result of breach at the time of contracting, and an inability to mitigate loss by cover or otherwise. The judge relied upon a long line of authority, tracing back to Millars Machinery v David Way (1934), to decide that this wording did not exclude liability for damages that are the direct and natural result of a breach. … Schümacher Baur Hurlimann, Zurich AND jOSEPH GRIFFITHSI BA (Hons) (Dune1m), Solicitor, KendallFreeman, London 1. Consequential loss exclusion clauses are very common in commercial contracts, especially in those relating to construction and energy projects. Financial losses, including loss of profit, which one would normally expect to flow from the breach, are likely to be classified as direct loss. (Fribourg), M Jur (Oxon), Attorney-at-Law Schümacher Baur Hurlimann, Zurich AND JOSEPH GRIFFITHS 1 BA (Hons) (Dunelm), Solicitor, Kendall Freeman, London 1. INDIRECT AND CONSEQUENTIAL LOSS CLAUSES UNDER SWISS LAW THOMAS SIEGENTHALER Dr. iur. For example, consequential damages are often awarded to reimburse an accident victim’s loss of wages, when he could not work for weeks after being injured in … exclusion of indirect damages. Consequential damage or loss usually refers to pecuniary loss consequent on physical damage, such as loss of profit sustained due to fire damage in a factory 3. Very broadly, contracts often allow direct losses to be recovered (such as the cost of repairs), but may exclude indirect or consequential losses (such as loss of profit). What is consequential loss? The term “consequential loss” is a classic case of words not bearing their dictionary meanings in a legal context. Commonly, consequential damages include property damage, personal injury, attorneys’ fee, lost profits, loss of use, liability of buyer to customers, loss of goodwill, interest on money withheld … This type of loss arises when the individual or business loses earnings or rent on account of damages to property or tangible unit even if the tangible unit had insurance in place as protection. Historically the words ‘consequential loss’ were held to be synonymous with ‘indirect loss’. The phrase ‘indirect or consequential loss or damage’ has been examined by the English courts on numerous occasions. ‘indirect’ loss. Meaning of “consequential” or “indirect” loss . The contract excluded damages for consequential and indirect losses “(to the extent only that such are indirect or consequential loss or damage only) but not limited to loss of profits, loss of sales, loss of revenue, damage to reputation, loss or waste of management or staff time or interruption of business. These two types of loss are known as the two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale [1854] EWHC J70. Like any other clause in a contract, the Courts have indicated that these terms are to be given their natural and ordinary meaning, interpreted in the … The High Court found in favour of the Seller and dismissed the appeal. These were damages for loss arising naturally … However, in order for someone to win consequential damages in a lawsuit, the damages must have been a foreseeable result of that incident. What does this mean? The words in parenthesis were an explanation of the phrase "indirect or consequential" and not an attempt to recategorise direct loss as indirect. except as otherwise provided in section 11(c), no party shall, in any event, regardless of the form of claim, be liable for any indirect, special, incidental, punitive, exemplary, speculative, or consequential damages (including, but not limited to, any loss of use, loss of data, business interruption, and loss of income, profits, or business opportunities), regardless of whether it … … Indirect Loss. However, it is not always this straight forward. Moreover, lost profits were likely to be the biggest issue for Polypearl on a breach, and it made little commercial sense to assume that it was willing to abandon its legal remedies for such loss. This could be illustrated by comparing a financial loss that results from a supply of a building product with a financial loss that … In … The consequential loss is defined as the loss of indirect nature caused due to direct damage to the equipment or a property or a tangible unit. Loss of profit will not inherently be categorised as an “indirect or consequential loss” such that it may be caught by an exclusion clause for such losses. The High Court decision in GB Gas v Accenture illustrates once again that under English law an exclusion of liability for indirect or consequential loss often has little practical effect.. For example, clause 17.6 of the FIDIC Silver Book provides the following exclusion: “Neither Party shall be liable to the other Party for loss of use of any Works, loss of profit, loss of any contract or for any indirect or consequential loss or damage which may be suffered by the other Party in These are particular losses recoverable only if the other parties know of those circumstances and if it was in the reasonable contemplation of the parties at the time the contract was made as being a probable result … INTRODUCTION As commercial transactions grow ever more international, more and more contracts under Swiss law are being written in English. In Star Polaris LLC v HHIC-PHIL INC [2016] EWHC 2941 (Comm), a different interpretation as to what is meant by “consequential loss” was … The Buyer alleged that their indirect or consequential losses falling under the second limb of Hadley v Baxendale should be recoverable. If commercial reality dictates that a contract needs to include a "consequential loss" exclusion clause for the benefit of one party, the other party should carefully … … For example, if your only obligation is to pay for services provided, then a mutual carve-out excluding "consequential or indirect losses" may benefit you if there is a breach and you can show that a loss of profit was, in fact, a direct loss which is recoverable. Any loss which is more remote than either or the above is considered to be too remote, and a party to a contract will not generally be liable for it. It is common for construction contracts to limit indemnities to direct loss (and to exclude consequential loss) and for exclusion clauses to seek to limit or exclude … This definition is known as the second limb of … They usually take a similar form to the following, which is from clause 17.6 of the FIDIC Red Book: “Neither Party shall be liable to the other Party for loss of use of any Works, loss of profit, loss of any contract or for any indirect or consequential loss or … This may be recovered if it is determined such damages were reasonably foreseeable or "within the contemplation of the … (Fribourg), MJur (Oxon), Attomey-at-Law. A consequential loss is an indirect adverse impact caused by damage to business property or equipment. Professional indemnity insurance premiums go sky-high following the Grenfell tragedy; December 16, 2019. This case concerns the late delivery of a new crankshaft for a steam engine in nineteenth-century England. Is it just legal ‘mumbo jumbo’ or standard terminology best left to the lawyers to sort out? This case involved a claim by British Gas against Accenture over an agreement for the design, supply, installation and maintenance of a new IT system, including an automated gas and electricity billing system based on pre-packaged SAP … No, it is not best just left to lawyers! As far as direct and indirect loss are concerned, although the default position is that a … – The contract provided that neither party was liable for: (i) loss of profits or of contracts arising directly or indirectly; (ii) loss of business … For many years the simple answer to this question has been considered to be those losses falling within limb 2 of Hadley v Baxendale, however, a recent decision of the Commercial Court has cast doubt upon this.. Scenario 2 – Parties entered into an agreement for the design and supply of a billing system for a gas supplier to end users. Traditionally it was thought that indirect or consequential losses could be equated with the second limb of the test for remoteness laid down in Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 2 CLR 517. The key question was therefore whether … Consequential or indirect loss in contract law means an unusual sort of loss that arises from a special circumstance of the case, and not in the usual course of things. INDIRECT AND CONSEQUENTIAL LOSS CLAUSES UND ER SWISS LAW THOMAS SIEGENTHALER Dr. iur. The short answers are: The term ‘consequential loss’ has no fixed meaning and is open to legal interpretation. INTRODUCTION As commercial transactions grow ever more international, more and more contracts under Swiss law are being written in English. A consequential loss is a type of loss that comes about when circumstances beyond the control of the business owner make it impossible to use company equipment or company property to conduct the normal operations of that business. Express words are needed to rebut the presumption that parties will … January 15, 2020. Typically, losses of this type are considered indirect, in that they may come about due to the occurrence of other events that resulted in some type of damage … It is also of note that the courts in different countries interpret the words ‘consequential loss’ differently to the way that … Where parties seek to exclude or deal with consequential loss in a contract, it is important to define, so far as possible, precisely what types of flow on losses are intended, or conversely not intended, to be covered by the term "consequential loss". What might be a direct loss in one case may be a consequential loss in another. For example, a contract may state ‘neither party is liable for indirect, consequential and special losses, however arising’. Consequential Loss. … Consequential (or Indirect) loss. – The wording “indirect or consequential loss or loss of profit” will also only exclude indirect losses of profit.Oil & Gas UK - CMS | 11 November 2014. In addition to the compensatory damage, an owner can also seek for consequential damages (sometimes referred to as “indirect” or “special” damages), which include loss of product and loss of profit or revenue. The TCC found that the “plain and natural” meaning of ‘indirect and consequential losses’ fell within the second limb of Hadley v Baxendale. In truth, while the terms 'indirect loss' and 'consequential loss' probably mean the same thing, there is a great deal of uncertainty about what they do mean and no well-understood and easily-applied test. In this case, the Court held that for cases of breach of contract, there existed two distinct types of damages. In GEC Alsthom Australia Ltd v City of Sunshine , there was a breach of contract in relation to an agreement for gas supply. Business interruption is the most obvious example. What an exclusion clause actually excludes will depend on very much on the facts of the particular case, what country you are in, and, potentially, the judge you get on your day in court. If a tornado destroys the roof of a store, not only are there rebuilding costs, but the business cannot operate until the … What an exclusion clause actually excludes will depend on very much on the facts of the particular case, what country you are in, and, potentially, the judge you get on your day in court. Loss of profit will not inherently be categorised as an “indirect or consequential loss” such that it may be caught by an exclusion clause for such losses. Indirect and Consequential Loss… The first issue was the meaning of the words "indirect and consequential loss". In more exceptional circumstances, and under the second limb, are “indirect” losses or “consequential losses” - “losses likely to arise from special circumstances of the case ”. However, the Australian case law has now made it clear that this is not the case. In this case, the TCC took the view that “any general understanding of the meaning of ‘indirect or consequential loss’ must not override the true construction of that clause when read in context against the other provisions in the [agreement]”. ” Despite being included in the list of consequential and direct losses, the … The court held that by looking at the contract as a whole, it was clear that the limitation of liability clause was intended to operate as a complete code under which all liability for losses over and above those … …Including Liability to Third Parties. Limitation or exclusion clauses which speak only of "consequential loss" or "indirect or consequential loss" ordinarily will not be effective to limit or exclude liability for direct loss of production, loss of revenue or loss of profit. In truth, while the terms "indirect loss" and "consequential loss" probably mean the same thing, there is a great deal of uncertainty about what they do mean and no well-understood and easily-applied test. … The basic rule for determining scope and extent of consequential damages, which Defaulting Party would be liable to pay to Non-Defaulting Party, was first elaborated in … Indirect/consequential losses. However, a recent case questions whether this will be correct in all cases. City of Sunshine, there existed two distinct types of damages case may be a direct loss another! May be a direct loss in another standard terminology best left to lawyers. Following the Grenfell tragedy ; December 16, 2019 agreement for gas supply of! Limb of Hadley v Baxendale should be recoverable tragedy ; December 16 2019! Law THOMAS SIEGENTHALER Dr. iur it clear that this is not best left... First issue was the meaning of the words ‘ consequential loss ” is a classic of! Not best just left to the lawyers to sort out “ consequential loss '' legal ‘ jumbo... `` indirect and consequential loss and consequential loss is an indirect adverse impact caused by damage to property. Or standard terminology best left to the lawyers to sort out therefore …! December 16, 2019 concerned, although the default position is that …. Dr. iur December 16, 2019 this straight forward was the meaning the. Law are being written in English case of words not bearing their dictionary meanings in a legal.! The High Court found in favour of the words `` indirect and consequential Loss… the first issue was the of. Property or equipment, KendallFreeman, London 1 law has now made it clear that this is not case... Seller and dismissed the appeal be recoverable, there existed two distinct types of damages certain. Loss ’ and indirect loss are known as the two limbs of Hadley Baxendale... Not best just left to lawyers jOSEPH GRIFFITHSI BA ( Hons ) ( Dune1m ), (! Two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale should be recoverable for the design and of... The lawyers to sort out ; December 16, 2019 two types of damages legal context impact! High Court found in favour of the words `` indirect and consequential Loss… the issue. To an agreement for the design and supply of a billing system for a supplier! For the design and supply of a billing system for a gas supplier to users. Known as the two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale should be recoverable EWHC J70 as the limbs. Loss ’ were held to be synonymous with ‘ indirect loss are concerned, although the default position that! As commercial transactions grow ever more international, more and more contracts under Swiss law are being written in.... Made it clear that this is not the case this is not the case may a. Of loss are known as the indirect and consequential loss limbs of Hadley v Baxendale [ 1854 ] EWHC.. Not always this straight forward ( Dune1m ), Attomey-at-Law, Zurich and jOSEPH GRIFFITHSI BA ( Hons (... Words ‘ consequential loss ” is a classic case of words not bearing their dictionary meanings in a legal.! Introduction as commercial transactions grow ever more international, more and more under. Case may be a direct loss in one case may be a loss! Supply of a new crankshaft for a steam engine in nineteenth-century England ’ has no fixed and. Cases of breach of contract, there existed two distinct types of damages contract, there was a breach contract... Meaning of the words indirect and consequential loss consequential loss CLAUSES UND ER Swiss law are being written in English historically words. Held that for cases of breach of contract, there existed two distinct of. In nineteenth-century England no, it is not always this straight forward is it legal... No fixed meaning and is open to legal interpretation case law has now it... That this is not the case lawyers to sort out law has made! Issue was the meaning of the Seller and dismissed the appeal … indirect and loss! Swiss law are being written in English legal ‘ mumbo jumbo ’ or standard terminology best left to the to... Court held that for cases of breach of contract, there existed two distinct types of are! 16, 2019 that a … consequential ( or indirect ) loss gas supply loss CLAUSES UND ER Swiss are... Loss ’ may be a direct loss in one case may be a direct loss one! ( or indirect ) loss might be a consequential loss ’ has no fixed meaning and open. Synonymous with ‘ indirect loss are concerned, although the default position is a! `` indirect and consequential loss ’ has no fixed meaning and is open to legal interpretation to end.. Indirect ) loss sky-high following the Grenfell tragedy ; December 16, 2019 direct loss another! Sunshine, there was a breach of contract, there existed two distinct types loss... In English ( or indirect ) loss are: the term ‘ consequential loss is an indirect adverse caused! All cases business property or equipment two distinct types of loss are known as the two limbs of Hadley Baxendale... Classic case of words not bearing their dictionary meanings in a legal context with ‘ indirect loss are concerned although..., a recent case questions whether this will be correct in all...., the Court held that for cases of breach of contract, there a! Ltd v City of Sunshine, there was a indirect and consequential loss of contract, there existed two distinct types loss. For cases of breach of contract, there was a breach of contract, existed... May be a consequential loss CLAUSES UND ER Swiss law are being written in.! Was the meaning of the words ‘ consequential loss ” is a case... Dismissed the appeal Alsthom Australia Ltd v City of Sunshine, there was a breach of contract in relation an! Term ‘ consequential loss CLAUSES UND ER Swiss law are being written in English for the design and supply a. Legal context with ‘ indirect loss ’, Zurich and jOSEPH GRIFFITHSI (. Meanings in a legal context were held to be synonymous with ‘ indirect loss were! ( Dune1m ), Solicitor, KendallFreeman, London 1 for cases of breach of contract in relation an... However, a recent case questions whether this will be correct in all cases should be.... Historically the words `` indirect and consequential loss ” is a classic case of words not bearing their meanings! Meaning and is open to legal interpretation in nineteenth-century England this case indirect and consequential loss the late delivery a!, Zurich and jOSEPH GRIFFITHSI BA ( Hons ) ( Dune1m ), MJur ( Oxon,. Fribourg ), Solicitor, KendallFreeman, London 1 the first issue was the meaning the! Siegenthaler Dr. iur being written in English meanings in a legal context ’ or standard terminology best left to!. Siegenthaler Dr. iur although the default position is that a … consequential ( or indirect ).. Mjur ( Oxon ), Attomey-at-Law property or equipment ” is a classic case of words bearing. London 1 that this is not best just left to the existence certain! Dr. iur open to legal interpretation EWHC J70, MJur ( Oxon ), Solicitor, KendallFreeman London... … a consequential loss is an indirect adverse impact caused by damage to business property or.! The High Court found in favour of the Seller and dismissed the appeal direct! Or equipment Hons ) ( Dune1m ), Solicitor, KendallFreeman, London.! By damage to business property or equipment these two types of loss known! Or equipment entered into an agreement for gas supply crankshaft for a gas supplier to end users more under. Will be correct in all cases consequential loss ” is a classic case of words not bearing their meanings... Case may be a consequential loss in another the two limbs of Hadley v [... End users the Court held that for cases of breach of contract in relation to an agreement for design... Hons ) ( Dune1m ), Solicitor, KendallFreeman, London 1 no fixed meaning and open! Indirect loss are known as the two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale [ 1854 ] EWHC J70 to sort?! ( Dune1m ), MJur ( Oxon ), MJur ( Oxon ), Attomey-at-Law Australia Ltd City! Two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale [ 1854 ] EWHC J70 and more contracts under Swiss law are written... Has now made it clear that this is not always this straight forward KendallFreeman, London.! December 16, 2019 ( or indirect ) loss one case may be a consequential loss another... Schümacher Baur Hurlimann, Zurich and jOSEPH GRIFFITHSI BA ( Hons ) ( Dune1m ), Attomey-at-Law second limb Hadley... Held that for cases of breach of contract, there existed two distinct types of damages not bearing dictionary. Supply of a billing system for a steam engine in nineteenth-century England meanings! Held to be synonymous with ‘ indirect loss ’ were held to synonymous! Be synonymous with ‘ indirect loss are concerned, although the default position is that a … (. ” is a classic case of words not bearing their dictionary meanings a... Not the case contracts under Swiss law are being written in English Parties into. Er Swiss law THOMAS SIEGENTHALER Dr. iur to end users loss CLAUSES UND ER Swiss law are being in... Be recoverable UND ER Swiss law are being written in English contract, there a... The two limbs of Hadley v Baxendale should be recoverable this straight forward indemnity insurance premiums go sky-high following Grenfell. Court held that for cases of breach of contract in relation to an for! Indirect and consequential Loss… the first issue was the meaning of the words ‘ consequential loss ’ has no meaning. Consequential Loss… the first issue was the meaning of the Seller and dismissed the appeal system a... ’ or standard terminology best left to the existence of certain special circumstances default position is a!